The Subject (Basis) of the Forensic Method for Investigating Intercorporate Theft in Insurance
https://doi.org/10.25205/2542-0410-2022-18-4-25-41
Abstract
The article discusses the conceptual issues of the theoretical prerequisites for the formation of a private forensic method for investigating intra-corporate theft in the insurance sector. The authors in the relevant aspect consider the content of the initial principles of the formation of private forensic techniques, characterize the related problems of the methodology of criminology. On the basis of the principles of immediacy, contiguity and interdisciplinarity adopted by the authors, the scientific reserve on the issues of criminalistic support for the investigation of fraud, other embezzlement and other crimes in the field of insurance is characterized. The “niches” for the prospective study of the problems of intra-corporate theft in the insurance sector are determined. The subject and place of the corresponding private forensic methodology in the system of forensic methodological knowledge are determined.
About the Authors
R. N. Borovskikh
Novosibirsk State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Roman N. Borovskikh, Doctor of Law, Associate Professor, Professor of the Department of Criminal Law
Novosibirsk
A. A. Serdyuk
Novosibirsk Law Institute (branch) of Tomsk State University
Russian Federation
Russian Federation
Alexander A. Serdyuk, lecturer of the Department of Criminal procedure and criminalistics
Novosibirsk
References
1. Agrenenko V. N. Prevention of crimes committed in the field of insurance: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M., 2003. 188 p.
2. Algazin A. I. Methodology of investigation of injury to health, accidents and death of insured persons. M., 2009. 120 p.
3. Algazin A. I., Zhukov A. B. Protection of business from insurance fraud. M.: Prospect, 2022. 200 p.
4. Algazin A. I. Methods of investigation of crimes committed in order to receive insurance payments: diss. cand. legal sciences. Omsk, 2003. 188 p.
5. Alexandrov I. V. Tax investigation: fundamentals of forensic methodology : monograph. Moscow : Yurlitinform, 2012. 384 p.
6. Belkin R. S. General theory of Soviet criminology. Saratov, 1986. 398 p.
7. Balyan A. V. Countering crimes committed in the insurance market: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M., 2006. 170 p.
8. Belyakov D. Y. Countering fraud committed in the field of auto insurance: criminological and criminal-legal aspects: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M., 2007. 167 p.
9. Bertovsky L. V. Problems of theory and practice of detection and investigation of criminal violation of the rules of economic activity: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. M., 2005. 526 p.
10. Borovskikh R. N. Basic criminalistic methodology of investigation of crimes in the field of insurance; Ed. by Y. P. Garmaeva. M.: Yurlitinform, 2018. 325 p.
11. Borovskikh R. N. Theoretical foundations and applied aspects of the investigation of crimes in the field of insurance: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. M., 2018. 455 p.
12. Bulgakova E. V. Features of the investigation and prevention of extortion and fraud committed by falsifying the circumstances of road accidents: Diss. Cand. Legal sciences. Saratov, 2003. 228 p.
13. Bykov Y. M. Fraud in insurance: criminological and criminal law problems: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2006. 196 p.
14. Bykova N. V. Detection and investigation of fraud in the insurance industry: diss. cand. legal sciences. M, 2009. 205 p.
15. Vardanyan A. V., Aivazova O. V. Principles of formation of private forensic techniques: current state and ways of improvement. Proceedings of Tula State University. Economic and legal sciences, 2016, no. 1–2, pp. 17–23.
16. Vozgrin I. A. Principles of methods of investigation of certain types of crimes. L., 1977. 80 p.
17. Gavlo V. K. Theoretical problems and practice of applying the methodology of investigation of certain types of crimes. Tomsk, 1985. 333 p.
18. Gitinov R. K. Methods of investigation of fraud in the field of auto insurance. M.: Yurlitinform, 2022. 200 p.
19. Gitinov R. K. Features of fraud investigation in the field of auto insurance: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M, 2017. 238 p.
20. Gorbachev A. V., Kolotushkin S. M. , Kochubey A. V. Tax crimes: fundamentals of technical and forensic support. Volgograd: VA of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2005. 172 p.
21. Grybunov O. P. Theoretical foundations and applied aspects of disclosure, investigation and prevention of crimes against property committed on transport: Diss. Doctor Legal Sciences. Rostov-on-Don, 2016. 543 p.
22. Egorov V. A. Criminalistic models of economic crimes in the credit and financial sphere. Sarat. jurid. in-t of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia. Saratov, 1999. 218 p.
23. Eliseev V. V. Prevention of crimes encroaching on the property of insurance organizations with compulsory insurance of civil liability of vehicle owners: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M, 2006. 222 p.
24. Zhuravlev S. Y. Methodological foundations for improving the methodology of investigating crimes in the field of economics: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2022. 520 p.
25. Zhuravlev S. Y. Typology of the mechanism of criminal activity of economic orientation and basic methods of crime investigation; Sc. Supervis. A. F. Lubin. N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2013. 423 p.
26. Zabavin D. V. Formation of a mechanism for ensuring financial security in the insurance sector (by the example of auto insurance): Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. M., 2008. 189 c.
27. Ievenko S. V. Improving the efficiency of loss settlement in an insurance company: Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. M., 2011. 143 p.
28. Kalyuzhny A. N. General methodology of investigation of crimes against personal freedom: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. Orel, 2022. 489 p.
29. Kozminykh O. V. Minimization of the insurer’s economic risks associated with the activities of financial and insurance intermediaries: Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. Saint-Petersburg, 2020. 262 p.
30. Kolesnichenko A. N. General provisions of the methodology of investigation of certain types of crimes. Kharkiv, 1965. 47 p.
31. Komissarov V. I., Lapin E. S. Investigation of thefts committed with the use of commodity credits. Moscow :LLC Publishing House “Yurlitinform”, 2001. 192 p.
32. Criminalistics: textbook; Ed. by N. P. Yablokov. M., 1999. 491 p.
33. Kuemzhieva S. A. Conceptual foundations of group methods of investigation of crimes against the family and minors: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. Krasnodar, 2020. 496 p.
34. Levshits D. Y. Criminal liability for financial fraud under the legislation of Russia and foreign countries: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. M., 2007. 217 p.
35. Lubin A. F. Selected works. Moscow: Blok-Print, 2021. 624 p.
36. Lubin S. A. Investigation of crimes in the field of insurance. Criminalistic provision of economic security and the fight against corruption: an educational and practical guide; Eds A. F. Lubin, S. Y. Zhuravlev. N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2012. Pp. 296–297.
37. Lyalin S. V. Ensuring economic security in the insurance system: Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. M., 2014. 161 p.
38. Maslov V. A. Criminal liability for insurance fraud: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Saint-Petersburg, 2015. 188 p.
39. Makhova I. V. Methods of fraud investigation in the insurance sector. In: Investigation of certain types of fraud: textbook; Eds A. G. Filippov, L. E. Chistovoy. M.: Yurlitinform, 2014. Pp. 80–94.
40. Miroshnichenko A. V. Mathematical modeling of insurance company risks: Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. M., 2008. 163 p.
41. Mitrichev S. P. Methods of investigation of certain types of crimes. M., 1973. 38 p.
42. Musyal I. A. Differentiated types of fraud: theoretical and practical problems: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Kursk, 2018. 259 p.
43. Abramov A. V. et al. Organization of investigation of crimes by internal affairs bodies; Ed. by B. Ya. Gavrilova. M., Academy of Management of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2013. 520 p.
44. Potapova N. N. Detection and investigation of fraud committed in the insurance business: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2006. 199 p.
45. Prometov S. V. Responsibility for encroachments in the field of insurance: legislation, legal analysis, qualification, causes and preventive measures: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2008. 247 p.
46. Sokol A. V. Economic security in the insurance sector and its provision by internal affairs bodies: Diss. Cand. Economic Sciences. M., 2007. 170 p.
47. Sukhomlinova L. A. Technical and forensic and organizational bases for the detection and investigation of fraud in the field of compulsory civil liability insurance of vehicle owners: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Volgograd, 2008. 197 p.
48. Trubkina O. V. Features of the initial stage of the investigation of fraud in the field of insurance committed in relation to the material interests of insurance companies: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Irkutsk, 2015. 226 p.
49. Urazbakhtin M. M. Criminalistic methodology of fraud investigation in the field of auto insurance: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Rostov-on-Don, 2013. 206 p.
50. Usachev S. I. Features of the use of special knowledge in the investigation of fraud in the field of auto insurance: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Kaliningrad, 2022. 222 p.
51. Fedotkin D. V. Organizational and economic aspects of the fight against crime in the insurance sector: diss. cand. economic sciences. M., 2001. 246 p.
52. Shaver B. On the basic principles of private methods of investigation of crimes. Socialist legality, 1938, no. 1, pp. 42–56.
53. Shmonin A. V. Methodology of criminalistic methodology. M.: Yurlitinform, 2010. 415 p.
54. Shcherbachenko A. K. Basic methodology of investigation of frauds committed by a group of persons: theoretical foundations and applied aspects: Diss. Doctor of Legal Sciences. Rostov-onDon, 2022. 431 p.
55. Yudintsev A. A. The use of economic information in the detection and investigation of crimes in the field of tax relations: Diss. Cand. Legal Sciences. Nizhniy Novgorod, 2005. 201 p.
Review
For citations:
Borovskikh R.N., Serdyuk A.A. The Subject (Basis) of the Forensic Method for Investigating Intercorporate Theft in Insurance. Juridical science and practice. 2022;18(4):25-41. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.25205/2542-0410-2022-18-4-25-41
Views:
381
Email this article 